ESIM problem on fairphone 6

Hi,

I m posting this post in english even there is a same topics in french (i ll put the link below). I hope like that that more people can advice us. We are already 2 users of new fairphone 6 encountering the same issue : we have activated esim with belgium orange operator and we cannot send nor receive any SMS.

I ll explain my situation (a little but different from Manon as she can make some calls, i don’t…unless i m connected to wifi or 4G) and try to explain the steps here :

-New fairphone 6 received in december (my 1rst one i was so excited to have chosen fairphone)

phone Working with google

-I have 2 sim cards, so i need to change one in an esim as fairphone6 has just one physical sim place, the other is esim in order to have dual sim mode. I changed my orange sim in esim.

I could easily scan and activate the sim card but quite quickly i see that i can’t text nor receive SMS. And also see that my number is disappearing from my esim card parameter when i desactivate the 4G call option. This is a littel bit playful because you don’t see that directly. (when having desactivated the 4G option, the number is still there, but if you go back to previous menu screen and go back to that screen option of 4G now desactivated, my phone number is not there anymore…)

If i reactivated the 4G calls option, same, i have to go back to screen to see well back my number….

I already change 3 times my esim card, erase, restart, try to change options, see RCS option,

my first status was connecting or something (don’t remember) and with this post : 🇫🇷 Je ne reçois pas les messages RCS , i don’t longer have any RCS field for this esim (i had force the stop, erase data of message app).

I have now done a back up and reset factory settings, reinstall my apps and so on…

Next step will be to have a 4th reinstallation of esim, i m crossing finger (and toes too :rofl: ) that the factory reset will change something….….

Thanks in advance for your help, ideas, …..

Christine

ps : here is the french post from Manon who has only the sms not working :

Hi
this might be a far fetched guess, but how about APN settings?

I have not seen these mentioned in my poor translation of Manon’s post either.

Hi Meaghan, as far as i remember this was ok.

As i no longer has the esim i cant be sure. I ll confirm you that tomorrow afternoon when going to the orange shop and having the esim back.

Have a nice evening,

Hi

It s finally working at the 4th Time.

I have first erase everything from my old Samsung phone.

I Back UP and reset in factory mode my fairphone.

Lost some things in the way because my Back UP was not entire :face_with_peeking_eye:

But if just went to orange shop and now it IS working well. I try SMS calls with and without wifi and it s ok now… so i don t know which part was the problem but it solved…

Hope this will help others.

Am having the same problem, with Salt (which is also Orange originally, but Switzerland). And resetting the APN (and restarting the phone and erasing the eSim, loading it again) doesn´t do anything.

Also have this problem, also with Salt (so Orange group), however in my case those are not all SMS, but only some. Usually longer ones, but not all long ones. Like i send 3 SMS in a row, 4th one, not longer, doesn´t work.

It might be a far shot but please double check with your message app whether it does not convert (some/long) messages into MMS.
If so, failing to send such could point to data/APN issue.

For example, on my FP5 MMS are failing if trying to operate them on a dual SIM scenario with the other SIM set as preferred for data.

Hi Meaghan, thanks for the ideas.

MMS convert > there is no such a setting available, it is inherent to Android/Google Message (without any available switch for the user). Before this FP6, with the same network providers and a Blackberry (dual sim/Android 12/Google message), it never happened.

SMS vs MMS display> when i write a message, the “send” icon on the right turns “SMS”, independent of the length, it doesn´t switch to MMS for example, which you clearly show this is turning it into an MMS.

MMS supported: 1 sim still support MMS (French), another one not (Swiss - country wide, no more MMS support - worked fine with my Blackberry on long text). And this is properly adjusted in the setting of Google Message respectively for each Sim. Yet, the message lenght poses problem on both Sim. A difference is that when sending fails, 1 sim proposes “send as SMS” (there is understand it´s a RCS topic, and SMS fixes it), and as i agree to send as SMS, it works. With the other Sim (eSim), it doesn´t offer that option (which is non sense, regardless whether i have RCS activated or not) and only say “send again” and it fails again.

Thanks for giving more examples. I don’t use RCS so I am not sure if I can stand the ground here, but doesn’t that suggest issue with data connection? I use Fossify messages and I had issues with MMS on it (also cannot send proper GIFs) but there is a setting on MMS.

For reasons above I am not sure I can fully recommend this app but in terms of troubleshooting? You could install the app, copy my settings and try to send a SMS message from both SIMs.

Salt needs an extra APN voor MMS.
At this page from Salt you can see the settings for the 2 APN’s

At their page is a fault in the text.
They stated:
’ Salt Switzerland MMS Settings for Android
MMS stands for Multimedia Messaging Service. To receive MMS on your iPhone and iPad, you must set MMS settings on Android.’

Clearly they mean here To receive MMS on your phone or tablet on Android,

Technically, MMS in Switzerland are not supported anymore. So text messages via Google Message only get sent either as RCS, or as SMS (“A text with more than 160 characters will be sent as multiple SMS”).

See below (all key Swiss network providers made similar PR:

Hi @Meaghan, brilliant idea the APN! I don´t understand how, after weeks of conversation with Salt, they didn´t come to that. And all my prior attemps to restore default setting didn´t help neither.

While i cannot tell yet whether it changes something for the SMS (as it is quite random on long messages), it did solve my other problem on modile data not working abroad while phone on roaming!

And here another useful link for Salt mobile users/Switzerland : Salt Mobile APN Internet Settings - Hello APN

Thank you ever so much!