English

Default data on SD card

Please don’t just close the thread before I get a chance to reply. That’s not ok.

So, apparently, FP2 cannot write to th SD card?

I don’t at all understand. What’s the deal? I very much want to put my data on the SD card (music, photos, etc.)…not on the phone itself.

What can I do? Can you point me to a simple fix for this?
I saw a thread about this, but it all seemed very complicated.

Br, Dl

The restricted writing access is the fault of Android 5. Security reasons :confused:. However, some apps can ask for writing access to the sd card, like Open Camera and the file managers Amaze and ES File Explorer. So you could change the default apps or copy/move your files with a file manager. For general writing access, you’ll need to root your phone.

1 Like

That’s horrible.

So, if I root my FairPhone2 - will I be able to make the camera save its images on SD card instead? And how?

A much easier alternative is using a different camera app. Did you find this thread when checking whether your question was already asnwered?:


Basically, a lot of apps haven’t been adapted to the new Android security model. Using apps that correctly request SD-card access works around the problem in the meantime.
Nothing is stopping you from copying music onto the SD card when it is connected to a computer. Most apps will be able to read these files from the SD card - it’s writing that’s the problem.

As for storing apps themselves; there’s no way to set the default install location to the SD card. Some apps can be moved there, but I would not recommend it, as there are plenty of complaints about ‘disappearing apps’ - which happens to apps on the SD card for instance when the SD card is accessed from a computer.

1 Like

Yes, I found that thread.
However, I was looking for a way to make the default apps on my phone work with my SD card. It seems crazy to me to make a phone that cannot use the SD card. Crazy crazy! I mean - if apps can use the SD card in spite of the new Android security models, why on earth didn’t the Fairphone people make the camera (and the other apps) do that? I thought it was supposed to be an ‘open’ phone…

You can vote for the relevant feature request here:
https://forum.fairphone.com/t/fp-os-os-feature-requests-vote-for-your-favorites/12303?u=johannes&source_topic_id=14115

Fairphone aims to be as open as possible in what they are doing (but there are some limitations). Being open does entail breaking the security model of an operating system, or providing all the features that every user may want. For the OS they provide, they make as much of the source code as possible available so that you could in theory make changes. They also facilitate as much as possible the option of installing other operating systems. It’s early days, so the latter will take a while to work. Meanwhile discussion about the source code for Fairphone OS, and how to compile it are here:

They just don’t deliver the phone with too many preinstalled apps, so everbody can install his/her favourite apps and doesn’t need to uninstall unwanted stuff. I use Open Camera and Camera ZOOM Fx (paid version) for example

@ Irina: It’s not about including many apps. It’s about making that one app (for instance the default camera app) work with SD cards.

@ Johannes: Voting, ok…and voting = liking?

But that’s the Google/Android default app. And Google have decided to restrict the access.

Yes, and then Fairphone should have chosen to make another default app…the new FP2 feels like a Google phone to me…

1 Like

Well, they took a decision to deliver the FP2 with preinstalled Google apps. I’m not happy about it, but there are solutions… And why should they developp an own Camera app, if the play stores are full of good different ones that meet the different needs of different users?

1 Like

Yeah, I see your point. It’s just as much a Google/Android problem as it is a FP2 problem. I guess I just expected the Fairphone people to create open features instead of relying on Google policies…

There will be an “official” Google free open source version of the OS, but we don’t know when. Some users already have build their own. So they really try to meet all needs.

1 Like

Hi @donleavy!

Fairphone is a small company and has not the resources to create replacement apps with (more or less) special features for a small (maybe niche) amount of users and for all apps you could think of. There’d be not that much benefit (in particular compared to the effort needed) of that either, because there are already plenty of apps out there fulfilling most of the needs, as @Irina_Spitznagel has already mentioned. I’d see no reason in repeating this work which has already been done.

Well, whether to include Google Apps or not is a huge question and lead to equally huge discussions in the past. Please refer to the following topics for these discussions:

Why i think Fairphone OS should drop root and pre-install Google Apps

Fairphone’s approach to root on the Fairphone 2

FP2 root or not root? How?

Poll: Should the Google Apps come preinstalled with the Fairphone?

If you want to get rid of Google (or parts of it), you’ll find a lot of help here in the forum:

Living without Google 2.0 - A Google free FP2

Alternative Apps(tores): Living without Google

Living with root and Google on the FP2?

@Irina_Spitznagel already mentioned the open source version of the OS. You can wait for it to be published by the Fairphone team (only info is 1st quarter of 2016) or you can compile it yourself, if you like:

[HOWTO] Compiling Fairphone Open Source / Rooting

4 Likes

continue here: