Sustainable smartwatch recommendations?

And it’s got some impressive runtimes:

Power reserve
· Stand-by mode: up to 18 months
· Activity tracking: up to 12 months
· Activity tracking + 2 hours heart rate: up to 6 months
· Activity tracking + 5 minutes heart rate: up to 30 days.
When the watch reaches 40%, we continue tracking your steps and stop Bluetooth® and below 10% the watch goes into time only mode.

I hate watches, but the black translucent one … :star_struck:
Way too expensive to buy on a whim though.

1 Like

luckily not all smartwatches have this awful ugly digital display with digital numbers
https://www.withings.com/de/de/scanwatch

I like the look of my Whithings Steel HR Sport, and I appreciate that it works (if you ban notifications) as a classic watch including activity/fitness tracker. But on the topic of sustainability:

Some day the glas cracked without interaction (and the button was stuck every now and then and the Bluetooth connection was quite a gamble), apparently the case was warped. Actually, I would have kept it, but the glass had to be repaired for water resistance. An agonizingly long discussion with support ensued (something along the lines of “have you reset the watch yet?”).
End of story: the glass could not be easily replaced, they replaced the watch. A throwaway gadget.

4 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 182 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.

Would love to see a smart watch in the future that follows the Fairphone ethics. I am a former Pebble user and would love to see a similar updated type device that provides the functionality of a smart watch but without the need to update super regularly. Would other be interested in the type of device or what are other people using that fit this bill?

Moved your post here, please see some recommendations above…

FYI I’m very happy with my PineTime. Probably not ethically sourced but open and hackable and the battery lasts almost a month between charges at this point (!). With enough work it’s like having an old-style microcomputer on my wrist. :slight_smile:

…and will we ever get one? They killed the buds, so i am thinking “not very likely”.
I really want a smartwatch, but they’re all kinda underwhelming. I just want something simple and beautiful, like the pebble (just not, you know…dead), and repairable. Not a sport centered feature monster or a watch that only really works with a smartphone from the same company.

1 Like

hello and welcome.
I do not think they killed the buds, I think they are working on an improved version.

4 Likes

I moved your post here, as I doubt we will see a Fairphone Smartwatch soon/ever and you might find some recommendations above.

1 Like

Be careful w/anything from Pine64. They are based in Hong Kong and give 1 month warranty.

You are aware of the Pine64 EU Store? According to the information there it should have the standard 2 year warranty and also ships from inside the EU, so no customs or CE issues to be expected. I bought my PineTime from them, but of course it’s much more expensive to begin with than ordering from China and trying to skip customs completely.
(Also, the watch seems to be out of stock right now.)

3 Likes

For their more expensive products this warning is 100% useful, but the PineTime costs £30. It’s so cheap I bought two (one an unsealed developer one for hacking on without bricking worries). It’s so cheap that you might as well treat it as throwaway if you break it: sending it back for repair would almost certainly cost more than buying a new one.

Thanks to the recent inflationary bout I literally spent more on takeaways yesterday than on my PineTime, and that was for only two people…

1 Like

I do get your point and I’m pretty sure you didn’t mean it like that, but I can’t agree with the implied carelessness regarding the “throwaway” nature of cheap electronic devices. We certainly don’t need more electronic waste. :thinking:

1 Like

Nope, I wasn’t aware of that, thanks! The price is a lot higher but it includes VAT, quicker S&H, and warranty.

I’m not interested in skipping customs as paying taxes is part of living in a civilized society. So the VAT should be added either way (and besides, usually they bust it these days in my country).

I also agree you can treat it like a burner (I saw a case/screen protector for it costs less than 1 USD on Ali).

But both last comments are a bit out of line with ‘sustainable’. PineTime is ‘hackable’. Can you repair it yourself? Not sure.

1 Like

Sorry, I did not want to imply that in your particular case, it was just a general statement as this is still a relatively common practice.

That really depends on the definition, I guess. If it lasts for a long time, it could be considered (more) sustainable. Having open firmware contributes to that. Actually hardware repairable smartwatches are something I have yet to see anywhere. But you only have to repair it if it breaks first. So far it’s looking good enough for my PineTime in that regard. The battery is or course a weak point in any such devices, but it might still last a decent amount of time.
Also, assuming that the hardware is decent enough quality, a lower price likely also means less resources were used in constructing the device. So it might be more sustainable than something with a lot more features and hardware. There are “smart” watches that cost 10 to 20 times as much, after all.

Also really happy with my Garmin Instinct Solar. Rugged smartwatch with limited features and long batterylife. In principle infinite if you turn off smart functions entirely.

Well, the non-devel version is sealed for waterproofing: you can break the seal and fix it but then you have to reseal it again. But in my case, I can’t fix anything in hardware because my coordination is too bad, so repairability by myself is not on my radar when I buy things :slight_smile:

(I got the unsealed devel version for access to the debug pins so I could plug in a Black Magic probe and debug things if I bricked it, not so I could repair it, and I could only manage to insert the probe after a dozen fumbled attempts. It looks as repairable as any other very small circuit board to me, but then as noted I never try to repair such things.)

Yeah the Swiss one 600 EUR lol.

For 30 or 60 EUR its sweet.

Are you able to disable radios like BT and WLAN from the smartwatch? I guess ideally I’d want physical killswitches but not practical.