Please read and cite the whole paragraph next time.
I fail to see, where we are in disagreement here.
I have just added bold face.
But how many people are there, that do need the phone the way your friend obviously does?
1 Like
Yes, but they are not moving towards their customers in regard to solving issues. Honestly, I am glad that any kind of hardware issue with a Fairphone can be fixed by a repair shop these days, because Lineage OS for my FP2 is rock solid and stable. Oh, and it is not provided by Fairphone, it is supported by volunteers whom - obviously - can be trusted more than Fairphone to supply instant support.
The fact is: Fairphone do not make their homework, which is the commitment to their products to give something to the customer, which has been expected for a higher price to be paid when compared with other phones, which - obviously - can be used to phone someone. Sure, we can agree on products that have the one or other fault that usually is corrected with a software update. But as far as I can see, Fairphone screw things up with every single update, making their products worse. They work on the next Android rollout when their products do not even work stable with the already supplied Android ROM.
As far as I can see, the “inability to talk issue” with the FP3(+) under certain circumstances has been existing from the very beginning, it started over a year ago. Compared with other brands, I am sorry to say that they react within a year to solve such an important issue with an update. Samsungs “battery gate” was a desaster, of course, it cannot be corrected with a software update. That is why I get the impression that some FP3 issues will not get fixed at all, because it might turn out that it is not possible to apply software patches when the cause of an issue lies deeper, in hardware architecture.
And because of these neck-stitching issues with Fairphone products combined with the lack of aftersales support, users are literally forced to “leave the movement” and buy an “unfair” product (again) that just does what it is made for: to phone someone and to be able to talk to this person. Especially old women and men rely on this basic function more than on chatting with people over the Internet.
2 Likes
While I won’t diminish the troubles you and others are facing with their phones and the support.
Please don’t take this experience for the Fairphone normal.
There are quite a few users in this forum as well, that
- have no issues with their phone, whatsoever
- have had great experience with support.
It is to be expected, that a forum like this attracts those users, that run into troubles.
I came here for the breaking of my FP2 cover (which was a design flaw and returned or rather stayed for a severe reboot problem with the FP2 as well. Support fixed both issues fast and in a very friendly way.
And you will find in this forum recent reports like that from FP3 users as well. So it’s not just “good old times”.
Dont get me wrong please.
You have every right to be frustrated, annoyed and angry, when you cant make calls with your phone and support does not react.
From reading in this forum I just wouldn’t come to the conclusion, that
“Fairphone does this and does not that”
For example, it might be a good idea to work on a new OS version, that will be fixing issues, when all efforts to fix those issues have been in vain. And it obviously is always a good idea to work on a new rollout to fix software related troubles.
Any problems related to hardware on the other side don’t hinder software development, as (my guess) programmers are not hardware designers but a different workforce. Stopping OS development would therefore not speed up hardware design. (But I might be wrong here, though I doubt it.)
5 Likes
Thank Alex, that’s all I could hope for. Just one point: It is not about feeling guilty or something like that. It is more that I am frustrated because I hoped, based on my initial positive impressions, that the FP3 would finally be a viable alternative I could recommend to my clients as business devices and I could recommend to friends and viewers - in my upcoming review . The fact that I can not do that is frustrating, that’s my main point.
2 Likes
I want to believe that is the case and I am still struggeling about how to present that in my review and verdict (for my clients and readers) about the FP3.
On the one hand I hope that unsatisfied customers and support experiences like mine are the exception. On the other hand I have exactly zero data to believe that. My own experience and the feedback in the forum, facebook groups and twitter, support my impression, that the fairphone 3 ist still buggy and fairphons knows it.
I asked fairphone - this time via official press contact - about failure rates, customer satisfaction and so on. They provided a generic answer without any data, not even customer satisfaction numbers of their own.
Every other brand I ever contacted had at least self evaluated numbers to share. In combination with my experience I am sorry to say that I can not agree with you that “this experience is not normal for fairphone”.
The fairphone business and communication practices are different from the industry, I agree, but I am not sure it is for the better. Which is a shame, because their positive contribution to the industry could be so much greater.
4 Likes
Thanks I know this chart, but with just 45 votes it is not better or worse than asking on social media for experiences. In other words: It is not what I would call good data. But thanks for reminding me, I can at least try to use it in my review.
1 Like
I hope the number of voters will increase - the poll is rather new - so the picture becomes a little clearer. Oh btw. when I first saw the poll, I thought that the unsatisfied votes will be the majority, because unhappy voices tend to be louder than happy ones. Let’s see how it unfolds further.
2 Likes
My review has to go live next week, but I hope that you are right and we will see more votes until then.
1 Like
Maybe I do not get it, but why are you naming this at all? Are you serious? To me, it sounds like “Oh, who needs to do emergency calls? Just so few people, wow. So, why make such a fuss about it?”
2 Likes
Hi everyone
I had the same problem and could solve it changing the top module. Fortunately I found someone in the used marketplace here in the community who sold it to me for a good price.
Don’t loos your passion for FAIRPHONE there have to be alternatives to the mainstream products.
Good luck
Gebhard
3 Likes
Hi Gebhard, my top module works fine - except when I make calls. 
It is sadly a software bug that I could not fix, even after resetting my phone. 
2 Likes
Hi, I can offer my two cents about how you feel. I was the owner of a FP2, among the preordering customers. The phone is neither usable nor repairable at a reasonable price last time I checked, because the screen connector on the motherboard module is damaged, and the core module is not offered as a spare part, and the price for changing it was too high (225€ at the time). In the meantime, I kept the phone for a few years, changing the screen 3 or 4 times under warranty because the sides got unresponsive. My feeling is that the phone was a draft modular phone, and I’m a cyclist keeping it in the pocket, which is not compatible. Pieces were slightly moving due to the stress on the phone, and degraded fastly. I felt betrayed because in the few years I kept the phone, there was very few moments when it was working flawlessly, although I had payed a good lot of money for the experience of a phone supposed to last long. I therefore believe that at that moment I felt what you are feeling right now.
Then I changed my mind and although I did not buy a FP3, because a friend of mine gave me his “old” phone and I believe that the best consumption is the one you don’t do, I believe I would if my current phone breaks. My opinion now is that Fairphone is probably more a goal than a true achievement. And they are going to make it because they are gaining support and popularity, thanks to people like me with too much money to spend on gadgets. In France I would be called a Bobo (Bourgeois Boème) and I probably am one. So now I consider myself as a necessary beta tester for the company to grow and improve their product. They need bobos, and I thankfully am one. Expressing my hate or disappointment would negate my impact on that growth, so I feel no regret for giving my money for them to use it in pursuing their goal while giving me the opportunity to use exhibit my cool but sometimes buggy modular phone and feel useful. Finally I must admit that I am not among the ones for which reliability is a true necessity, so all in all that was a cool experience.
6 Likes
There is something I don’t understand: What does make you think it is a software bug ? I could argue it is not since I don’t have this problem on my FP3 which uses the last software released by Fairphone.
2 Likes
I think there can be specifc settings, or a specific configuration (I don’t know for sure), that create or influence this issue.
My point is, the fact you don’t have it and he does isn’t a proof it’s not software related.
Though I totally agree with you it would be a good idea to check it’s really a software issue and not a hardware one. But from what I understood from @sozialpr’s post, I think he did (?)
1 Like
I think of it in much the same way. Which is probably why, if I were to use a phone or distribute phones for business purposes, I would probably go with one of the cheaper Samsung models, depending on the nature of the company. For private use, however, I’m willing to take a risk in favour of idealism. So far that worked out well for me, so based on my personal experiences, I wouldn’t mind using the FP3 for business purposes. However, knowing others do have issues and Fairphone is not yet an established brand like other phones, it’s probably not ready for being a business phone.
3 Likes
Becaus I did multiple rounds of tests with the support team and they came to the same conclusion as I did: It is a software bug, becaus mit to module works in Messenger-Calls and for listening to voice messages, but it does ot work in normal phone calls. Plus my microphone is fine - except when I try to make calls.
3 Likes
So it could be the dialer or the provider, have you tried VoIP apps or other dialer apps?
Missed that part
I would try other dialers, or force-quit, uninstall, reinstall your current app
1 Like
Yes we - meaning the support and I - tried. Everything works - except when I take normal calls.
1 Like
There might be one hardware related cause of the issue though:
There are numerous reports in the forum about the FP3 not recognizing any headphones for common audio playback. (The sound still comes from the speaker after the headphones have been plugged in.) Instead, the internal microphone is muted. The only thing I can think of in this regard is that the phone falsely “silences” audio input instead of output. And if those two signalling lanes were mixed up on the mainboard (hardware), that could be a reason for not being able to fix this unless the mainboard is revised/exchanged.
3 Likes