Not at all, questioning is the foundation for discussion. Notice how I say ‘reasonable’ not ‘right’ The fact that there are flaws in this update is undeniable, possibly more flaws than features. I, personally, much more appreciate people who balance good facts with the lesser ones. I do not judge people who tend to express their regards, negative or positve. Ofcourse, and this is undeniably typical for us, human beings, commenting on someones failures is a lot easier than -once again- balancing your thoughts.
As I’m not a native English speaker, perhaps I shoudl’ve chosen my words more carefully. What I meant by ‘reasonable’ is calm (yes written text can be calm or aggressive), critical yet polite and more or less ‘neutral’.
I agree completely with how you say that the forum is being bombed with negativity, perhaps this ‘clouds’ my judgement, can’t argue with that. I was just trying to express how for us, moderators (but I may speak for myself here), it is nice to see a post which is not completely negative yet balanced and constructive.
But, for the time being, I’ll stop complaining as I understand all frustrations and issues, yet on the other hand: I see what the Fairphone team tries to do, and I’m just imagining how they’re feeling at the moment as well, and we can all imagine and possibly agree that that won’t be a pleasant feeling.
Let’s just keep in mind that we’re all human beings and humans make mistakes (‘errare humanus est’).
To finish, as a community moderator I’m obliged to keep the thread going one way and not diverting in (possibly for some) useless directions, so I’ll stop going down the philosophical/ethical road
If you have any comments regarding my judgement and replies, please feel free to PM me, I’m very open to criticism if directed to me personally.
EDIT:
By the way, do we come over as such unreasonable moderators? :’( I don’t think anyone has ever been banned for questioning a moderator? The only reason users have been banned on this forum was for posting spam