English

Latest news [11-07-2017] and FAQ - Fairphone 1 KitKat 4.4.4 update

I think you are talking about the KitKat port by @chrmhoffmann?

It is indeed not possible for Fairphone to encourage that build because FP1’s software is not open source. @chrmhoffmann’s build is compiled from many different unofficial sources he found around the web.

Regarding your feature hypothesis: The reason that Fairphone hasn’t released a new alpha build for a while is simply that it doesn’t boot. :frowning:

2 Likes

It’s working about as well as Fairphone’s build. I don’t recall if bluetooth worked fine, though. It did have newer Android (4.4.4) with security updates up to May 2016.

Sure, as otherwise it would work worse than the last official Fairphone OS (1.8.7)!

Though my arrogant opinion is that these top 2 bugs are minor issues¹, and having Android 4.4.4 with latest security updates would outweigh them :relieved:

¹ well, at least battery level drops, as it’s just the algorithm showing battery level, not actual battery life.

2 Likes

That’s unfortunate, as it is quite the whole point! :wink:

I’m not so sure… Note the word “new” in “new feature”, in my message.

Wow! That’s big news. Such an important distinction should definitely be more public. While I understand how imperfect reporting can be unnerving to some users, some users won’t care; I wouldn’t.
There’s still the unreliable bluetooth, though…

According to my experience Bluetooth is unreliable and does work worse than it should.
But it is better than 1.8.7. I wouldn’t consider this a reason to halt the upgrade. (But solving it afterwards would be nice.)

I’m currently using the alpha. But if one thing were to prevent me from upgrading it would be the battery level bug.
Yes, the phone lasts as long as usual but you can’t trust the percentage. If I didn’t carry an external battery pack all day this would be a big issue for me.

2 Likes

The unofficial 4.4 OS is weird. Yes, it works.
But we don’t know where the parts came from. @chrmhoffmann is unlikely to have access to all of the source code.
This ROM is a normal Android 4.4.4 (with all bugfixes applied) and a combination of various binary blobs found on the internet.

I would say yes. (But I’m not a lawyer.)

But there’s another problem:
If you read @jftr’s posts you know that one of the big problems in porting Android to the FP1 is the Mediatek code intertwined with the normal Android code.
@chrmhoffmann doesn’t have access to this code.
So even though the security fixes have been applied to the Android code,
the Mediatek specific things are old (some even from older Android versions). We don’t know what bugs and holes are in them.

I don’t think so.

I would say yes. I would release the pre3 as-is to all customers and solve the remaining problems in future updates. But that’s just me. I’m glad not to have make this decision.

1 Like

As said above, at the moment there is no new build that even boots. You can however download the latest alpha here. It’s been made public for everyone a while back.

That doesn’t contradict what I said?

Thank you @YtvwlD for those explanations. You helped me decide that next bootable update, be it alpha, beta, or final (one can always hope), should make it to the FP1 at home :slight_smile:
The unofficial version, however, won’t ever do it for me.
Cheers,

2 Likes

I overread that you where talking about pre3. Still, Fairphone isn’t too perfectionist. At the moment @jftr is simply working on making 4.4.4 bootable. So there is no fancy new feature involved.

Also, pre3 is released to all customers, it is just not available through the FP updater.

2 Likes

Hello, in the opening of this thread I read about the two issues with 4.4.4. (Bluetooth does not work reliably with all the devices, and the battery level also keeps dropping unexpectedly.)

That’s really funny, I don’t need Android 4.4.4 Kit Kat for these issues. They´re accompanying me since 3 years. In the meantime, I’ve got the impression that’s quite normal.
My second impression also is a bit strange. I received a mail from Fairphone that says my Fairphone is almost at the end of its life cycle. After three years - that’s extremely fair! It contradicts the company philosophy. On the other hand the update for the FP1 lasts and lasts. It seems as if the first customers (the useful idiots) are forced to buy the FP2.

FYI, referring to your second impression:

2 Likes

Yes, and behind Mediatek Android code, there’s modem baseband firmware, which nobody has access to and probably contains security holes.

https://www.fsf.org/blogs/community/replicant-developers-find-and-close-samsung-galaxy-backdoor

If you want to be safe, use :telephone_receiver: :cold_sweat:

2 Likes

A post was split to a new topic: FP1 crashes all the time

2 posts were split to a new topic: Why is this post flagged?

So what is the last working KitKat Version for FP1 and where can I download it?

pre3 is the last release.

2 Likes

Is it possible for Fairphone to add FP1 to LineageOS for LOS 14.1 (Android 7.1.2)? I’m referring to that other phones with proprietary blobs from pretty much every manufacturers are made available without any support from neither the manufacturer nor proprietary hardware manufacturers like MediaTek or Qualcomm. I’m guessing there is a group of handy programmers owning FP1 who’d like to see a newer version of Android than KitKat 4.4.4?

The chipset vendor alone is not relevant. What is much more relevant in this regard is thee specific chipset, in FP1’s case MT6589. As far as I know there is no other phone with that chipset that has received LineageOS.

Apart from that the FP1 developer community is practically non-existent.

Edit: You could of course try this xda porting guide for cm 11: https://forum.xda-developers.com/android/general/guide-port-cyanogenmod-10-2-11-mt6589-t2814498

3 Likes

Thank you. Do you by the way know, if theres a Fairphone updater apk available somewere for thes build. I lost mine somehow.

Hi douwe,

Where could I see it? I would like to help.

Thanks

2 Likes